Running a company

Company vs sole trader in NZ: when it's time to incorporate

By Eclipse AccountingPublished Last reviewed 7 min read

The short answer

As a sole trader, your profit is taxed at your personal rates, 10.5% to 39%, and the business's debts are yours. A company is a separate legal entity that pays 28% on its profit and takes more admin. There is no set income for switching; it depends on the profit you leave in the business, your risks and your plans.

In this article
  1. Two ways to run the same business
  2. How a sole trader is taxed
  3. How a company is taxed
  4. Limited liability, and its limits
  5. What a company takes to run
  6. When incorporating tends to make sense
  7. GST works separately from this choice
  8. Moving an existing business into a company

The short answer: neither is better in every case. A sole trader pays personal tax rates, 10.5% to 39%, on all of the business profit and is personally responsible for the business's debts. A company pays 28% on its profit, generally limits what a shareholder can lose, and takes more admin and cost to run. Whether a company works out better for you depends mainly on how much profit you leave in the business, how much risk you carry and what you plan to do next.

Two ways to run the same business

Starting as a sole trader is simple. There's usually no formal process: you trade in your own name, use your personal IRD number, and the profit is yours. As the business grows, the question of moving it into a company comes up. Neither is right for everyone, and the reasons to change are as much about risk and plans as about tax.

Here is how the two compare:

Compared Sole trader Company
Who owns the business You The company, owned by its shareholders
Tax on the profit Your personal rates, 10.5% to 39% 28% in the company
Tax returns Your own return (IR3) A company return (IR4), and usually your own IR3 for what you take out
The business's debts Yours personally The company's. A shareholder's liability is generally limited
Taking money out Drawings. You're taxed on the whole profit Salary, dividends or drawings, each taxed differently
Set-up and upkeep Usually no formal process Registration, an annual return and company records

How a sole trader is taxed

As a sole trader, the business profit is part of your personal income for the year. Tax isn't deducted before you're paid, so you pay it after the year ends, through your own return (IR3).

Inland Revenue's personal rates from 1 April 2025:

Income Rate on each dollar
Up to $15,600 10.5%
$15,601 to $53,500 17.5%
$53,501 to $78,100 30%
$78,101 to $180,000 33%
Over $180,000 39%

What you take out of the business for yourself is called drawings. Drawings aren't a wage and aren't a business expense, so they don't reduce your taxable profit. You're taxed on the whole profit, whether you draw it or leave it in the bank. Once the tax left to pay at the end of a year is more than $5,000, you'll also pay provisional tax in instalments the following year.

How a company is taxed

A company is a legal entity in its own right, separate from its shareholders. It has its own IRD number, files its own tax return and pays tax on its own profit. For most companies the rate is 28%.

You're taxed personally on what you take out of the company:

  • A shareholder salary. It can be paid with PAYE deducted, like any employee's wages, or worked out at the end of the year, in which case no tax is deducted and you pay it through your own return.
  • Dividends. The company can pay dividends out of profit it has already paid tax on, and attach imputation credits for that tax. The credits reduce the tax you pay personally on the dividend, so the company's profit isn't taxed twice.

Profit you leave in the company is taxed at 28% while it stays there. When it is paid out later as a dividend, it becomes part of your personal income, generally with imputation credits for the company tax already paid. So the company rate makes the most difference to profit you leave in the business to grow it, pay down debt or build a buffer.

Money you take during the year, before your salary or dividend is decided, usually goes through a shareholder current account. If that account goes overdrawn, it can have tax consequences. Our article on shareholder current accounts explains how they work and how owners keep them in order.

Limited liability, and its limits

A company's debts are its own. Under the Companies Act, a shareholder isn't liable for the company's obligations just because they are a shareholder, unless the company's constitution makes shareholder liability unlimited. A shareholder's liability to the company is generally limited to any amount unpaid on their shares, anything the constitution expressly provides and liability under the directors' duties sections (131 to 137). In practice, if the business runs into trouble, what a shareholder stands to lose is generally limited to their stake in the company.

That protection has limits worth knowing:

  • Personal guarantees. If you personally guarantee a lease, a loan or a supplier account, you are liable under that guarantee, company or not.
  • Directors' duties. Directors must act in good faith and in what they believe to be the best interests of the company, and the Companies Act sets out further duties, including not agreeing to the business being carried on in a way likely to create a substantial risk of serious loss to creditors (reckless trading, section 135), not agreeing to the company taking on an obligation unless they believe on reasonable grounds it can be performed (section 136), and a duty of care (section 137).

How these apply to your contracts is a question for your lawyer, and it's worth asking before you sign.

What a company takes to run

A company involves more than a sole trader business does. Expect:

  • Registration with the Companies Office, which has a fee. Reserving the company name costs $10 plus GST. Every company needs at least one director, one shareholder and one share, and at least one director must live in New Zealand (or live in Australia and be a director of an Australian-incorporated company), per the Companies Office. The company's IRD number can be applied for at the same time.
  • An annual return to the Companies Office each year, during the month allocated to the company, for a fee of $49.74 plus GST. It isn't needed in the calendar year the company was registered, so the first one falls due in the following calendar year. It confirms the company's details and is not the same as a tax return.
  • A company tax return (IR4) every year, and usually a personal return (IR3) for each shareholder who takes money out, such as a shareholder salary with no tax deducted.
  • Records that keep the company separate from you: its own bank account, a shareholder current account for money in and out, and decisions about salary and dividends made and recorded properly.

None of this is difficult, but it is ongoing. It's part of the cost of the structure, alongside any accounting fees.

When incorporating tends to make sense

There's no income figure in the tax rules that tells you it's time. These are the situations where owners most often find a company starts to earn its keep:

  • Profit is more than you need to live on. If you'd rather leave some profit in the business, a company taxes it at 28% while it's there, instead of at your top personal rate (33% on income over $78,100 and 39% over $180,000).
  • The risks are growing. Staff, a lease, bigger contracts or borrowing all mean more at stake, and limited liability starts to matter.
  • Someone else is coming in. Shares make ownership clear when a partner or investor joins, and a company can take in money from more owners.
  • The business is becoming something separate from you. A company keeps the business's assets, debts and records apart from your own.

And where it may not be worth it yet:

  • You need all the profit to live on. If it all comes out as salary or dividends, it's taxed at your personal rates either way, so the company rate makes less difference and you carry the extra admin.
  • You contract your own services, mainly to one client. Inland Revenue's attribution rule is aimed at stopping people avoiding higher personal tax rates by diverting income from their personal services to a company or other associated entity. It applies only in particular circumstances, including where at least 80% of the entity's personal-services income comes from one buyer (and their associates), at least 80% of that income is earned by the working person or a relative, and the working person's net income is over $70,000. If it might apply to you, get advice before incorporating.

GST works separately from this choice

GST is a separate question from income tax. Inland Revenue says an entity carrying out a taxable activity must register for GST if its turnover was at least $60,000 in the last 12 months, or it expects turnover to be at least $60,000 in the next 12 months. Below that, you can choose to register. The test is turnover, not profit, and it isn't a tax rate comparison, so it doesn't answer the sole trader or company question on its own.

Moving an existing business into a company

The company is a separate legal entity, so moving your business into it means the company takes over the business and its assets from you. That has tax points to work through, such as how the price is split across the assets, which Inland Revenue says generally must be based on market values. It's worth planning the move with your accountant before it happens rather than tidying it up afterwards.

A company isn't the only option either. Some owners use a look-through company, or a trust as a shareholder. Which fits depends on the business, the family and the plans, which is what tax planning and structuring is for. If you're weighing up the change, a short call is a good place to start.

FAQs

Questions people ask

Do sole traders pay less tax than companies in New Zealand?

Not as a rule. A sole trader pays personal rates, from 10.5% to 39%, on all of the business profit. A company pays 28% on its profit, and you pay personal tax on the salary or dividends you take out, with imputation credits for tax the company has already paid. Which works out better depends on how much profit you leave in the business and on your other income.

Is it better to be a sole trader or a company in NZ, and is there an income level to switch?

There's no figure in the tax rules that tells you when to incorporate. Personal rates step up to 33% on income over $78,100 and 39% over $180,000, so the gap with the 28% company rate matters more as profit grows, especially profit you leave in the business. Risk, partners and your plans for the business count as much as the numbers.

Does a sole trader have to register for GST, and does a company?

Inland Revenue says an entity carrying out a taxable activity must register for GST if its turnover was at least $60,000 in the last 12 months, or it expects turnover to be at least $60,000 in the next 12 months. Below that you can register voluntarily. The test is turnover, not profit, so it is separate from the income tax question of sole trader or company.

Does a sole trader count as a company?

No. A sole trader isn't a separate legal entity, so the owner is personally responsible for the business's debts. A company is a legal entity in its own right, separate from its shareholders (Companies Act 1993, section 15).

Talk to us about your company

We'll recommend the right services and give you a clear quote after our first call.

Book a free callCall